I was 12 at the time and completely unaware about what was going on in New York's Greenwich Village – and who knows if the disturbance even received news coverage in Pittsburgh (after all, the city's first Gay Pride parade wasn't held until just six years ago!). And even if it was reported I wouldn’t have understood much since at that age I didn’t even know what a homosexual was. (A few years later I’d learn by sneak-reading my older sister’s copy of Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex*.)
The only memory I have that has some connection to the event was hearing about the death of Judy Garland on the car radio as my family drove to church on the Sunday preceding Stonewall. At the time my only association with her was as Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz, and not as a gay icon. Legend has it that her death was a contributing factor to the riot (along with a heat wave) as her funeral was earlier that day and bar patrons weren’t in the mood to be harrassed by police (but that has since been called into question).
Not to digress too much, but 17 years later I was living in the belly of the beast, the West Village, just a few minutes’ walk to the Stonewall Inn. During that summer of 1986 I participated in a sit-down protest that blocked traffic on Seventh Ave. for an hour or so on the evening of July 1. It was in response to the Supreme Court upholding Georgia’s sodomy law. And so I had my own opportunity to participate in a bit of civil disobedience.
But getting back to the disturbance at Stonewall, an event that ignited the gay rights movement, the account that follows is provided by Liz Solomon, a former co-worker of mine, who grew up in Greenwich Village. She kindly volunteered to offer her story of that night. Take it away, Liz …
First off, let me say that the thoughts and language of this memoir are those of 1969 not 2009. I cringe at some of the things we said and did back in those days. But more importantly, I am a firm believer in historical accuracy trumping political correctness.
It’s important to understand that the West Village of 1969 was a very different place than it is today. For one thing it wasn’t called the West Village, but rather “Downtown”, “West Side”, maybe “the Village”. Furthermore, it wasn’t the home of celebrities, models – and especially not the rich. It was a regular working/lower middle class neighborhood with dock workers, butchers (the Meat Packing District actually processed meat back then!), truck drivers along with a scattering of white collar workers and government employees.
We always knew there were gay people interspersed in the neighborhood but it had yet to take on the “gay ghetto” vibe that came later in the 70s. (When I was in high school and college, guys I dated from outside the neighborhood would often give me a hard time about walking me home when they learned where I lived because it might be bad for their "image" if they were spotted there). Did we welcome those of differing orientations with open minds and hearts? Much as I’d like to say yes, we were kids and it was 1969. But it wasn’t a matter of thinking that homosexuals were deviant. No, they were just different, and there was getting to be more of them in OUR neighborhood and they were starting to take over the docks after dark, previously the urban version of "lover's lane" for a neighborhood full of frisky and hormonal teenagers. No doubt some of the local boys felt a bit uncomfortable or threatened by overt homosexuality (not that they would admit it), but any harassment, name calling, or even occasional fisticuffs was really more a matter of “turf”, not orientation, and would have been even worse had the interlopers been from, say, 17th Street.
Which brings us to the last weekend of June, 1969. I admit I missed the first night entirely. The police raid on the Stonewall Inn happened after 1:00 AM and at the time I had a curfew so I was long home under lock and key. The next day was Saturday and a family obligation kept me off the stoops and out of the loop until after dinner. The minute I could I broke away and once outside the air was buzzing with incredulous and somewhat amused chatter about how the gays actually fought back, throwing stuff, shouting about their rights and turning the tables on the police - at least for a while.
This animated discussion continued as more and more kids joined the “hanging out” group. Then someone suggested we walk over to Sheridan Square (two blocks away) to witness what was going on firsthand. It was about 9:30 and, WOW, was it ever crowded with an agitated throng shouting previously unheard messages of gay pride and solidarity. Cops were everywhere with their billy clubs in hand and ready to go. The tension was beyond anything I could remember in my limited experience. Anyway, we were just onlookers and this wasn’t our fight. Except that anyone starting trouble against our tormenters from the 6th Precinct, who enforced truant laws and chased us off street corners, was officially okay in the neighborhood kids’ book. The enemy of our enemy was our friend, thus did some dispassionate teenagers become involved in the opening act of the battle for Gay Rights.
I remember being pushed along with a group of my friends and other people to the other side of Sheridan Square towards West 4th St. Fires lit in garbage cans and there was was considerable harassment (but restraint as well) on both sides. I saw a lot of shoving, and a few outright beatings, but alas, once again, my curfew loomed (plus a small grace period) and I had to make my way to the safety of home. Thus my first participation in civil disobedience, albeit I was somewhat on the peripherary, came to an end.
The following year on June 28 New York City held its first Gay Pride Parade as an estimated 2,000 participants marched through the streets of Greenwich Village. Since then a number of other key moments in Gay History have also occurred in late June: the unfurling of the first Rainbow Flag at San Francisco's Gay Pride Parade on June 27, 1978; the striking down of the nation's sodomy laws by the Supreme Court on June 26, 2003; and on June 30, 2005 MTV debuted its gay-themed cable network, Logo.
(Two books that provide in-depth background on the Stonewall Riots are Stonewall: The Riots That Sparked the Gay Revolution and Stonewall.)